I’ll come right out and say that when I’m reading a fantasy book set in a time and place analogous to real human history (and aren’t they all?) I expect some level of ‘historical accuracy’.
The right amount of historically accurate details judiciously applied is the sprinkling of salt that makes the butter of a story taste like heaven. It helps to create reader immersion. In the same way I wouldn’t step into a lift made of papier mache, nor would I want to spend time in a world that doesn’t...